Cookie Exchange Recipes

Showing  1–20 of 57

16 Brownies
Main Ingredient: Chocolate
12 Servings
Main Ingredient: Fruit
1 Dozen
Main Ingredient: Other
4 Dozen Cookies
Main Ingredient: Grain
16 Squares
Main Ingredient: Chocolate

These cutout cookies are buttery and crisp with hints of caramel from the dark brown sugar. They are perfect for any occasion where you want a sweet and beautiful treat.

4-5 Dozen
Main Ingredient: Other

Buckeyes are a classic candy from the Ohio region. They are made of a soft peanut butter center dipped partially in chocolate. The finished candy resembles a Buckeye nut.

5 Dozen Candies
Main Ingredient: Nut

This buttery sugar cookie is the perfect base for your fanciest decorating ideas. They're easy to roll out and have a buttery, crisp texture when baked.

4 Dozen Cookies
14 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Grain
16 Bars
40 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Grain
24 Servings
20 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Grain
16 Bars
30 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Chocolate
8 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Grain

Rich chocolate shortbread is a decadent treat. To ensure even pieces, cut the shortbread into squares after it comes out of the oven, while it’s still hot.

18 Cookies
1 hours
Main Ingredient: Chocolate
1 Pound
Main Ingredient: Chocolate

This lightly spiced cookie is whimsical and tasty. Decorated simply with melted chocolate it is sure to delight the kids and adults in your life.

2-3 dozen cookies
1 hours & 30 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Other
Main Ingredient: Grain

These could be the most delicious (and easiest) bar cookies we've ever made. A few pantry ingredients combine to make a delectable treat.

18 Bars
25 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Grain

Chocolate and peanut butter are a perfect pair, especially when made into these truffles. You'll wonder how you ever lived without this recipe around the holidays! It's a quick and easy vegan candy that makes the perfect holiday gift.  

15-20 truffles
30 Minutes
Main Ingredient: Nut
4 Dozen Cookies
Main Ingredient: Nut

Delicate and buttery shortbread cookies filled with lemon curd.  What could be better? These cookies are sure to be a hit at any holiday party.   

3 dozen cookies
Main Ingredient: Grain